Decision-Making Skills – Behavioral Interview Answer

Posted on by

In today’s competitive job market, employers are looking for candidates who can make sound, thoughtful decisions—even when faced with multiple proposals, competing priorities, and tight deadlines. For job seekers and students entering the workforce, demonstrating strong decision-making skills during an interview can set you apart from other candidates.

Why Employers Ask This Question

When an interviewer asks, “Tell me about a time when you had to evaluate several proposals or ideas and make a suggestion,” they are assessing:

  • Whether you approach decisions with logic and fairness
  • How you prioritize competing ideas
  • If you can analyze information and collaborate with others effectively

Decision-making isn’t just about choosing one option—it’s about balancing data, stakeholder input, and long-term goals.

How to Structure Your Answer

One of the best ways to answer is to use the STAR method (Situation, Task, Action, Result). This keeps your response clear, concise, and results-focused.

Example Good Answer:

“Recently, I was tasked with reviewing four proposals for updating our scoring model to better serve a specific group of applicants. I analyzed the data for each model and ran simulations to predict outcomes. None fully met our criteria, so my team and I created two new models that integrated the best aspects of the originals. After running more simulations and gathering stakeholder feedback, one model clearly outperformed the rest—both in data and community support—so we recommended it for implementation.”

This answer shows analytical thinking, collaboration, adaptability, and a results-oriented mindset.

Key Tips for Job Seekers & Students

  • Always show that you considered all options before making a decision.
  • Highlight the data and feedback you used.
  • Demonstrate fairness and strategic thinking.
  • Show how your decision had a positive impact.

Conclusion

Strong decision-making skills are essential in any career. By preparing examples where you analyzed multiple ideas and made a well-supported choice, you’ll demonstrate to employers that you can think critically, balance competing priorities, and lead effective outcomes—qualities that can make you a top candidate.

Author

Established since 2009, Jobs Section has emerged as the leading staffing solutions provider that has set a proven track record for matching the right people to the right organization within the shortest time. With our vast network of resources, extensive databases and defined recruitment processes, we have been successfully bridging talented job seekers of the highest caliber to employers who only want the best in their teams. In our relentless pursuit of excellent service, we have adopted best practices and dynamic growth strategies in expanding our operations across country.